The Wordsmith's Forge

There are lots of possible candidates:

1) Griffin with completely freaked-out expression.

3) Ass with head tilted sideways. (For a great visual pun on the pinball table TILT as slang for anything shaken out of order.)

6) The winged asp is desperately hiding from the man with the book.

8) Everyone has frogs coming out of their mouths. (For those days when your Weird Shit-O-Meter goes "AAAAOOOOGAH!" ... and then falls off the post.)

11) Whale with a completely freaked-out expression, chased by a boat.

12) Panther cornered by a bunch of other animals.

17) Cat with a drum looking askance at a donkey blowing a horn. (For when other people are driving you bugfuck.)

33) Completely freaked out, fleeing manticore.

37) Pard with a horrified expression.