ysabetwordsmith (![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
ysabetwordsmith) wrote2013-05-08 01:45 am
ysabetwordsmith) wrote2013-05-08 01:45 am
Entry tags:
Hurt/Comfort and Literary Merit
As part of the ![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
three_weeks_for_dw project (running April 25-May 15), I'm posting some content just to Dreamwidth. This is a good opportunity to seek new readers for your blog and new blogs to read, and to recommend stuff you enjoy on other people's blogs to help them make new connections too. Here is a set of posts about hurt/comfort literature. Start with "Hurt/Comfort as a Genre" and "Hurt/Comfort Plot Structure."
Hurt/Comfort and Literary Merit
Some people look down on hurt/comfort as inferior to other types of writing. This is no more true of hurt/comfort than it is of any other literature that people like to disrespect. Any genre, plot dynamic, mood, or other literary motif may be done well or poorly. There is nothing inherently laudable or disgraceful about them. It depends on the individual merits, or lack thereof, concerning a specific example. A genre may attract more or fewer serious writers compared to people who just want to fool around for fun, and therefore, may trend lighter or heavier, smoother or sloppier, depending on taste. But it's always possible to have good and bad examples.
Hurt/comfort is sometimes criticized for fetishizing other people's pain. Take a look at literature in general, and most of it does that to some degree, except for gentle fiction and early childhood fiction. Horror and its relatives, and mystery, lie heavily at the "hurt" end of the spectrum and may contain little or no comfort. They're all about watching people squirm. Romance is another genre widely mocked for being shallow, unrealistic, sometimes voyeuristic.
All that stuff is okay -- it's just storytelling. Storytelling is what humans do. We imagine things for fun. Other times we imagine things to warn each other away from potential danger, whether physical or psychological. Sometimes we also imagine things to think about what we might do in a similar situation. Hurt/comfort posits that, if somebody is sick or injured, you do your best to help. That's a solid foundation for human decency. An interest in that is not something to mock.
There are, of course, different reasons to read and write literature of any kind, not just hurt/comfort. Some people do it just for fun, especially fanfic. Some seek catharsis -- a way to get troublesome emotions from the inside to the outside, where they will be less of a bother. Some seek to communicate, a factor which drives the exchange of author/audience interaction, particularly in fanfic and crowdfunding venues. Some desire a pinnacle of craft, the artistry of language and literature; this is more common in original work, but also appears in fanfic. Some wish to make money, the purview of original work from which we get whole new canons to enjoy. There are mountains beyond mountains; there are many more motives people may have. These are just a few of the popular examples.
All of these reasons for reading and writing are okay. It's great to have options, to have different goals. Ideally, you know what your own goals are, and those may vary depending on your mood at the time. Know what you like. Know how to find or make it. Don't disrespect what other people are doing. Don't listen if other people try to put down what you enjoy either. Storytelling is for everyone. Tell ALL the stories.
How do you feel about the quality of hurt/comfort stories you have read or written? Do you find discussions of literary genres to be fun and welcoming, or full of wank?
three_weeks_for_dw project (running April 25-May 15), I'm posting some content just to Dreamwidth. This is a good opportunity to seek new readers for your blog and new blogs to read, and to recommend stuff you enjoy on other people's blogs to help them make new connections too. Here is a set of posts about hurt/comfort literature. Start with "Hurt/Comfort as a Genre" and "Hurt/Comfort Plot Structure."Hurt/Comfort and Literary Merit
Some people look down on hurt/comfort as inferior to other types of writing. This is no more true of hurt/comfort than it is of any other literature that people like to disrespect. Any genre, plot dynamic, mood, or other literary motif may be done well or poorly. There is nothing inherently laudable or disgraceful about them. It depends on the individual merits, or lack thereof, concerning a specific example. A genre may attract more or fewer serious writers compared to people who just want to fool around for fun, and therefore, may trend lighter or heavier, smoother or sloppier, depending on taste. But it's always possible to have good and bad examples.
Hurt/comfort is sometimes criticized for fetishizing other people's pain. Take a look at literature in general, and most of it does that to some degree, except for gentle fiction and early childhood fiction. Horror and its relatives, and mystery, lie heavily at the "hurt" end of the spectrum and may contain little or no comfort. They're all about watching people squirm. Romance is another genre widely mocked for being shallow, unrealistic, sometimes voyeuristic.
All that stuff is okay -- it's just storytelling. Storytelling is what humans do. We imagine things for fun. Other times we imagine things to warn each other away from potential danger, whether physical or psychological. Sometimes we also imagine things to think about what we might do in a similar situation. Hurt/comfort posits that, if somebody is sick or injured, you do your best to help. That's a solid foundation for human decency. An interest in that is not something to mock.
There are, of course, different reasons to read and write literature of any kind, not just hurt/comfort. Some people do it just for fun, especially fanfic. Some seek catharsis -- a way to get troublesome emotions from the inside to the outside, where they will be less of a bother. Some seek to communicate, a factor which drives the exchange of author/audience interaction, particularly in fanfic and crowdfunding venues. Some desire a pinnacle of craft, the artistry of language and literature; this is more common in original work, but also appears in fanfic. Some wish to make money, the purview of original work from which we get whole new canons to enjoy. There are mountains beyond mountains; there are many more motives people may have. These are just a few of the popular examples.
All of these reasons for reading and writing are okay. It's great to have options, to have different goals. Ideally, you know what your own goals are, and those may vary depending on your mood at the time. Know what you like. Know how to find or make it. Don't disrespect what other people are doing. Don't listen if other people try to put down what you enjoy either. Storytelling is for everyone. Tell ALL the stories.
How do you feel about the quality of hurt/comfort stories you have read or written? Do you find discussions of literary genres to be fun and welcoming, or full of wank?
no subject
I guess fanfiction is often criticized because it's not published, not official, and a lot of people don't know about it and have an uninformed opinion about it.
And like you said, hurt/comfort is a particular genre, it doesn't seduce the majority, it's more confidential. Like horror, you like it or not. I don't like horror, but I don't go judging those who do, I understand that, like you explained, it can be cathartic, or just plain fun.
I'm becoming more difficult to please now in my reading, and I don't read badfic as much as I used to (also, I got better in english, so I guess the bad writing is a lot more of an issue for me now !!)
Thanks for these discussions, it's interesting and enjoyable!
Thank you!
Re: Thank you!
Re: Thank you!
Re: Thank you!
Re: Thank you!
Re: Thank you!
Re: Thank you!